Skip to main content

Establishment profile

PERKINS CINDERS, INC.

1950 EAST ADAMS, SHOW LOW, AZ, 85901
212321Construction Sand and Gravel Mining

Download as PDF →

OSHA inspections
2
over 21 years
Violations
1
Penalties
$0
$0 avg
Violations across 2 federal agencies
Enforcement actions from multiple agencies may indicate systemic compliance issues across functions.
Accident investigations on record
5 OSHA follow-ups

Summary

PERKINS CINDERS, INC. has accumulated 1 OSHA violation across 2 inspections over 21 years of recorded history.

The most recent federal enforcement activity was recorded 2 months ago.

Federal records were found in 2 of 15 sources. Sources without matching records returned empty for this establishment.

Agency coverage

PERKINS CINDERS, INC. appears in OSHA workplace safety, MSHA mine safety, and FMCSA motor carrier registration records only. No matching records were found in WHD wage enforcement, EPA environmental compliance, NLRB labor relations, OFLC visa and labor certification (historical), SAM.gov federal debarment, CMS nursing home enforcement, UVA Corporate Prosecution Registry, CPSC product recalls, or NHTSA vehicle recalls.

OSHA workplace safety

Inspections
2
0.1 / yr · last 21 yrs
Violations
1
0.0 / yr
Penalties
$0
Inspection trigger · planned
2 of 2

50% of inspections at this establishment produced violations,

Most-cited OSHA standards

Top OSHA standards cited at this employer, ranked by citation count. Standards (CFR sections) cluster citations into safety themes -- machine guarding, lockout-tagout, hazard communication, fall protection, process safety, etc. A concentration on one or two sections reveals a pattern that individual citations don’t. 1 distinct standard shown · 1 citation in this view.

CFR sectionCitationsInspectionsTotal penaltyFirst citedLast cited
29 CFR 1926.0251 A0411Jun 2005Jun 2005

Source: OSHA inspection citations (violation_detail). CFR section codes can be looked up at osha.gov/laws-regs for the formal standard text. Per-inspection detail and the specific violation descriptions are available by expanding individual inspections below.

Safety self-report (OSHA 300A)

No self-reported injury rates filed with OSHA's Injury Tracking Application for PERKINS CINDERS, INC.. Verify directly with OSHA Injury Tracking Application

Industry benchmark

Industry avg TRIR
1.5
BLS SOII 2024
Industry avg DART
1.0
BLS SOII 2024
Self-reported TRIR
Not in OSHA ITA

BLS rates reflect industry-wide averages. Self-reported figures come from OSHA’s Injury Tracking Application; absence of self-reported data does not necessarily indicate non-compliance — many establishments fall below the ITA reporting threshold.

Inspection breakdown

Planned
2

Complaint- and accident-triggered inspections are stronger risk signals than routine planned inspections.

OSHA severe injury reports

No severe injury reports (hospitalization, amputation, or loss of an eye) on file under 29 CFR 1904.39 for PERKINS CINDERS, INC.. Verify directly with Occupational Safety and Health Administration

Activity timeline

Data refreshed
Weekly
First OSHA inspection
Most recent activity
2 months ago

Most recent federal enforcement activity recorded 2 months ago. Data on this page is refreshed weekly.

Wage & Hour Division (WHD)

No WHD wage, overtime, or child-labor enforcement cases on file for PERKINS CINDERS, INC.. Verify directly with Wage and Hour Division

Mine safety (MSHA)

Company-level in AZ — for PERKINS CINDERS, INC., not this location alone

Violations
251
Assessed penalties
$48,352

Mine Safety & Health Administration — citations issued at mining operations. MSHA records cases at the company/regional level (no worksite address), so these are matched by company name and state and may span other PERKINS CINDERS, INC. operations in the same state.

MSHA citations

Mine Safety and Health Administration citations. S&S (significant and substantial) marks violations that could reasonably contribute to a serious injury. Negligence rating is MSHA’s operator-culpability assessment (none, low, moderate, high, or reckless disregard). Proposed = assessed at issuance; Paid = post-settlement / appeal. 100 citations · 49S&S · 4 contractor · $34,599 proposed / $29,922 paid.

CitationMineDateSectionS&SNegligenceProposedPaid
6308157
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Dec 2004YesHighNegligence$3,200$2,436
6295508
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Oct 2003YesModNegligence$1,500$750
6310041
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Aug 2005YesModNegligence$838$838
6310037
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Aug 2005YesModNegligence$838$838
6292312
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
May 2002NoModNegligence$796$796
6292311
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
May 2002NoModNegligence$796$796
5058851
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Jul 2025YesHighNegligence$755$755
6295515
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Oct 2003YesModNegligence$723$506
6295505
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Oct 2003YesModNegligence$723$506
6295518
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Oct 2003YesModNegligence$715$500
6274338
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Jan 2003YesModNegligence$655$655
6306414
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Nov 2006NoHighNegligence$600$600
6310038
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Aug 2005YesModNegligence$524$524
6310036
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Aug 2005NoModNegligence$524$524
9908428
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Jul 2024YesModNegligence$492$492
6292313
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
May 2002NoModNegligence$486$486
5052118
Aztec plant
Navajo, AZ
Jul 2025YesHighNegligence$465$465
9908429
Aztec plant
Navajo, AZ
Jul 2024YesHighNegligence$453$453
6308158
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Dec 2004NoModNegligence$440$308
6308148
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Dec 2004NoModNegligence$440$308
6295499
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Oct 2003YesModNegligence$440$308
6295498
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Oct 2003YesModNegligence$440$308
6295517
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Oct 2003NoModNegligence$435$305
6295516
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Oct 2003NoModNegligence$435$305
6295513
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Oct 2003YesModNegligence$435$305
6295509
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Oct 2003NoModNegligence$435$305
6295504
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Oct 2003NoModNegligence$435$305
6295500
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Oct 2003YesModNegligence$435$305
9153548
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Mar 2022YesModNegligence$407$407
6274341
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Jan 2003NoModNegligence$399$399
6274340
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Jan 2003NoModNegligence$399$399
6274339
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Jan 2003YesModNegligence$399$399
6310039
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Aug 2005NoModNegligence$350$350
9301127
Silica Services Mining, LLC
Apache, AZ
contractor: Perkins Cinders Inc.
May 2017YesModNegligence$339$339
6295512
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Oct 2003NoModNegligence$324$227
9652412
Silica Services Mining, LLC
Apache, AZ
contractor: Perkins Cinders Inc.
Jul 2022NoModNegligence$321$133
6295510
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Oct 2003NoModNegligence$321$225
6295502
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Oct 2003NoModNegligence$321$225
6295497
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Oct 2003NoModNegligence$321$225
6459150
Hall Pit
Apache, AZ
May 2023NoHighNegligence$302$302
6295503
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Oct 2003YesModNegligence$302$211
6295501
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Oct 2003YesModNegligence$302$211
6308155
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Dec 2004NoLowNegligence$286$200
6583776
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
May 2010YesModNegligence$285$285
6295506
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Oct 2003NoLowNegligence$283$198
9301137
Silica Services Mining, LLC
Apache, AZ
contractor: Perkins Cinders Inc.
May 2017YesModNegligence$280$280
9300688
Cooley Knoll Pit
Navajo, AZ
May 2017YesModNegligence$280$280
7947586
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Apr 2001YesModNegligence$277$277
6583781
Linden Pit
Navajo, AZ
Jun 2010YesModNegligence$263$263
6308156
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Dec 2004NoModNegligence$247$173
6295514
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Oct 2003NoModNegligence$245$172
6295507
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Oct 2003NoModNegligence$245$172
8596012
Cooley Knoll Pit
Navajo, AZ
Sep 2012YesModNegligence$243$243
6587239
Cooley Knoll Pit
Navajo, AZ
Jun 2010YesModNegligence$243$243
6292310
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
May 2002YesModNegligence$207$207
6292309
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
May 2002YesModNegligence$207$207
6292306
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
May 2002YesModNegligence$207$207
6295511
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Oct 2003NoModNegligence$201$141
6292464
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Sep 2002YesModNegligence$196$196
6292461
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Sep 2002YesModNegligence$196$196
6306416
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Nov 2006YesModNegligence$191$191
6310040
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Aug 2005NoLowNegligence$191$191
6308150
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Dec 2004YesModNegligence$177$177
9908431
Aztec plant
Navajo, AZ
Jul 2024NoLowNegligence$168$168
9908432
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Jul 2024NoLowNegligence$164$164
9908430
Aztec plant
Navajo, AZ
Jul 2024NoModNegligence$164$164
6292462
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Sep 2002YesModNegligence$161$161
7945406
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Feb 2000YesModNegligence$161$161
7945405
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Feb 2000YesModNegligence$161$161
7945404
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Feb 2000YesModNegligence$161$161
5058853
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Jul 2025NoModNegligence$151$151
5058852
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Jul 2025NoModNegligence$151$151
5052117
Aztec plant
Navajo, AZ
Jul 2025NoModNegligence$151$151
5052116
Aztec plant
Navajo, AZ
Jul 2025NoModNegligence$151$151
6274342
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Jan 2003NoModNegligence$150$150
6309974
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Mar 2001NoModNegligence$150$150
9827410
Aztec plant
Navajo, AZ
Nov 2024NoLowNegligence$147$147
9726974
Aztec plant
Navajo, AZ
Jul 2024NoModNegligence$147$147
9908409
Hall Pit
Apache, AZ
Jul 2024NoModNegligence$147$147
9903855
Aztec plant
Navajo, AZ
Feb 2024NoModNegligence$147$147
9903854
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Feb 2024NoLowNegligence$147$147
9726903
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Jun 2023NoLowNegligence$143$143
9726902
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Jun 2023NoHighNegligence$143$143
9726901
Aztec plant
Navajo, AZ
Jun 2023NoHighNegligence$143$143
6459152
Hall Pit
Apache, AZ
May 2023NoModNegligence$143$143
6459151
Hall Pit
Apache, AZ
May 2023NoModNegligence$143$143
6859071
Aztec plant
Navajo, AZ
Mar 2023NoModNegligence$143$143
6859043
Hall Pit
Apache, AZ
Mar 2023NoModNegligence$143$143
6859042
Hall Pit
Apache, AZ
Mar 2023NoModNegligence$143$143
7947584
FIRST KNOLL PIT
Navajo, AZ
Apr 2001YesModNegligence$140$140
7947582
FIRST KNOLL PIT
Navajo, AZ
Apr 2001YesModNegligence$140$140
7947581
FIRST KNOLL PIT
Navajo, AZ
Apr 2001YesModNegligence$140$140
7947579
FIRST KNOLL PIT
Navajo, AZ
Apr 2001YesModNegligence$140$140
9652410
Silica Services Mining, LLC
Apache, AZ
contractor: Perkins Cinders Inc.
Jul 2022NoHighNegligence$133$133
9153549
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Mar 2022NoModNegligence$133$133
9301750
Cooley Knoll Pit
Navajo, AZ
Dec 2018YesModNegligence$132$132
8755251
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Apr 2013YesModNegligence$127$127
8595869
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Oct 2012YesModNegligence$127$127
8595866
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Oct 2012YesModNegligence$127$127
8584699
Owens Pit
Navajo, AZ
Jul 2011YesModNegligence$127$127

Source: MSHA citation database. “Contractor” annotations indicate the cited party was on-site at the mine but not the mine’s operator -- responsibility attaches to the contractor LLC, not the mine’s owner. Section codes reference 30 CFR (the Mine Safety and Health regulations).

Labor relations (NLRB)

No NLRB unfair labor practice charges or union representation cases on file for PERKINS CINDERS, INC.. Verify directly with National Labor Relations Board

Visa & labor certification (OFLC) — historical

No H-1B, H-2A, or H-2B labor condition applications on file (historical data only — DOL ended OFLC publication) for PERKINS CINDERS, INC.. Verify directly with Office of Foreign Labor Certification

Environmental compliance (EPA)

No EPA inspections or formal enforcement actions on file for PERKINS CINDERS, INC.. Verify directly with Environmental Protection Agency

Motor carrier safety (FMCSA)

DOT number
1247154
Operation
A

Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration — DOT-regulated carrier registration and fleet data.

Federal criminal prosecution record

No federal criminal prosecutions, plea agreements, or deferred-prosecution agreements on file for PERKINS CINDERS, INC.. Verify directly with UVA Corporate Prosecution Registry

Federal contracts

This location

Obligated (5-yr)
$3.2M
Obligated (all-time)
$4.0M
Awards
34
Top agency
Department of Agriculture
$4.0M
Top agencies by obligation (this location)
Department of Agriculture$4.0M
Department of the Interior$20K
Largest awards
  • Department of Agriculture
    A-S NFSR 26 SURFACING STABILIZATION, REHABILITATE EXISTING ROAD SURFACE, ADDING NEW GRAVEL AGGREGATE.
    contract · Last action 2025-03-26
    $1,710,179
  • Department of Agriculture
    IIJA(BIL) LEGACY ROAD AND TRAILS FUNDED PROJECT WILL RESHAPE THE ROAD SURFACE AND THEN APPLY A 4" THICK STABILIZED AGGREGATE SURFACE. THIS WILL IMPROVE DRIVING CONDITIONS FOR A HEAVILY TRAVELLED ROAD AS WELL AS REDUCE SEDIMENT RUNOFF INTO THE W
    contract · Last action 2025-05-21
    $847,048
  • Department of Agriculture
    FY 23 NKRD ROAD MAINTENANCE ML3 AND ML2 ROADS THROUGHOUT DISTRICT
    contract · Last action 2023-09-29
    $212,038
  • Department of Agriculture
    AGGREGATE, LINE ITEM B2.1, 3/4 INCH MINUS CRUSHED ROCK, 15,150.8 TONS, $13.09 PER TON (NFSR 182 185 FOR RE-SURFACING, RECONSTRUCTION AND MAINTENANCE OF DRAINAGE STRUCTURES, SPOT BORROW AND ROCK TRIMMER TO BRING ROADS UP TO ML REQUIRED FOR HAULING)
    contract · Last action 2016-04-27
    $198,709
  • Department of Agriculture
    ROAD MAINTENANCE ON MRRD ML3 AND ML2 ROADS THROUGHOUT THE DISTRICT
    contract · Last action 2023-09-29
    $169,371
  • Department of Agriculture
    AGGREGATE SUPPLY FOR 4FRI 2 PREPARATION ENG -PRESALE ROAD MAINTENANCE AND RECONSTRUCTION OF ML 2&ML 3 NATIONAL FORESTS SYSTEM ROADS FOR RESTORATION PROJECTS MILLIGAN VALLEY&GREENS PEAK !CFLR005
    contract · Last action 2017-05-04
    $150,000
  • Department of Agriculture
    STOCKPILE AGGREGATE, 2017, NFSR 285 SURFACING AND STABILIZATION
    contract · Last action 2017-06-26
    $133,569
  • Department of Agriculture
    STOCKPILE AGGREGATE FOR HAULING TO 4FRI PRIORITY ROADS AND OTHER ROAD MAINTENANCE AND DRAINAGE SUPPORT ACTIVITIES.
    contract · Last action 2024-03-19
    $83,563
  • Department of Agriculture
    ROAD MATERIAL APACHE SITGREAVES NATIONAL FOREST USDA
    contract · Last action 2025-02-21
    $51,851
  • Department of Agriculture
    ENG - URAR FLEMMING&BILLY STOCK PILED AGGREGATE (IDIQ)
    contract · Last action 2018-06-22
    $50,000
  • Department of Agriculture
    STOCKPILE AB (ITEM B2.1, SHOW LOW) FOR URAR ROAD PROJECTS !CFLR005 4FRI 2. PROJECT PREP ENG -PRESALE ROAD MAINT/ RECONST UPPER ROCKY ARROYO(APPRENTICE, TELEPHONE)
    contract · Last action 2018-11-20
    $47,366
  • Department of Agriculture
    CRUSHED 1 INCH MINUS BASE COURSE AGGREGATE SPRINGERVILLE AGGREGATE IDIQ
    contract · Last action 2021-04-01
    $46,720
  • Department of Agriculture
    2540 D1 ENG LOCO KNOLL SURFACE ROCK REPLACEMENT IDIQ
    contract · Last action 2020-08-28
    $44,989
  • Department of Agriculture
    ROADS MATERIAL APACHE SITGREAVES NATIONAL FOREST USDA IDIQ
    contract · Last action 2022-07-11
    $39,992
  • Department of Agriculture
    STOCKPILE AGGREGATE, 2017, SURFACE ROCK REPLACEMENT ON SPRINGERVILLE DISTRICT
    contract · Last action 2017-09-19
    $35,000
  • Department of Agriculture
    2591 SO ENG AGGREGATE PURCHASE IN SUPPORT OF 4FRI ROADS ON SPRINGERVILLE RANGER DISTRICT
    contract · Last action 2020-04-01
    $34,599
  • Department of Agriculture
    RENTAL OF EXCAVATOR FOR USE IN SUPPORT OF WALLOW FIRE.
    contract · Last action 2011-06-12
    $31,152
  • Department of Agriculture
    JUNE AND JULY FIRE SEASON
    contract · Last action 2011-06-01
    $31,152
  • Department of Agriculture
    0301 Q3 ENG 21 APACHE ROAD MATERIALS NEW OUT ARIZONA FOREST ENGINEERING AND ROAD MAINTENANCE (FERM) BLANKET PURCHASE AGREEMENT REQ #1154578 NRE-2411 DOGE APPROVED AGGREGATE MATERIAL
    contract · Last action 2025-08-06
    $30,000
  • Department of Agriculture
    0301 Q4 CON ENG 21 ROAD MATERIAL NEW OUT AGGREGATE MATERIEL
    contract · Last action 2024-04-10
    $29,480
  • Department of Agriculture
    0301 Q3 ENG 28 SITGREAVES ROAD MATERIALS NEW OUTARIZONA FOREST ENGINEERING AND ROAD MAINTENANCE (FERM) BLANKET PURCHASE AGREEMENT BPA CALL SEE SCHEDULE REQ 1154579 NRE-2410
    contract · Last action 2025-08-06
    $20,000
  • Department of Agriculture
    AGGREGATE MATERIALS, IDIQ ITEM NUMBER B2.1 1,375 TONS 3/4 INCH MINUS CRUSHED AGGREGATE TO PERKINS CINDER INC. AG-8173-C-13-0020
    contract · Last action 2017-09-27
    $17,999
  • Department of the Interior
    PIT RUN FOR BAGGING NEEDED FOR BURN AREA EMERGENCY REHAB FOR LOCUST FIRE.
    contract · Last action 2012-04-12
    $11,539
  • Department of Agriculture
    STOCKPILE AB AND 3"MINUS MATERIAL FOR IDIQ ROAD PROJECTS
    contract · Last action 2016-09-27
    $10,000
  • Department of the Interior
    4"-8" COBBLE ROCK FOR EMBANKMENT RESTORATION
    contract · Last action 2016-10-13
    $8,585
  • Department of Agriculture
    EERA 0296A WYRICK 06/23-25/21 E81, TRACTOR/TRAILER, 8P3N3B821
    contract · Last action 2021-07-01
    $1,740
  • Department of Agriculture
    STOCK PILED AGGREGATE FOR MAVERICK TRAIL GRANT
    contract · Last action 2023-10-17
    $0
  • Department of Agriculture
    ARIZONA FOREST ENGINEERING AND ROAD MAINTENANCE (FERM) BLANKET PURCHASE AGREEMENT
    contract · Last action 2023-02-10
    $0
  • Department of Agriculture
    SITGREAVES ZONE AGGREGATE IDIQ
    contract · Last action 2021-02-23
    $0
  • Department of Agriculture
    APACHE ZONE AGGREGATE IDIQ
    contract · Last action 2021-02-23
    $0
  • Department of Agriculture
    2017 AGGREGATE SUPPLY IDIQ - MAS
    contract · Last action 2017-06-23
    $0
  • Department of Agriculture
    2013 AGGREGATE SUPPLY IDIQ
    contract · Last action 2016-08-26
    $0
  • Department of Agriculture
    IGF::OT::IGF VIPR I-BPA FOR HEAVY EQUIPMENT FOR REGION 3 - SOUTHWEST REGION
    contract · Last action 2014-04-29
    $0
  • Department of Agriculture
    VIPR I-BPA FOR MISCELLANEOUS HEAVY EQUIPMENT FOR REGION 3 - SOUTHWEST REGION
    contract · Last action 2012-06-15
    $0

Federal contract dollars to this establishment. Primary NAICS: 237310 - HIGHWAY, STREET, AND BRIDGE CONSTRUCTION. Last action: 2025-08-06. Source: USAspending.gov, net obligations. Recipient address is the SAM registration / HQ address, not necessarily the worksite.

Inspection history

DateTriggerViolationsSeriousPenalty
2026-04-08Planned0$0
2005-05-17Planned1$0

Source: OSHA IMIS. Citation amounts reflect initially assessed penalties; final amounts after appeal may differ.

In the news

Other employers in this industry and state

Other employers in construction sand and gravel mining within AZ, ordered by federal enforcement volume:

Related searches

About this data

This profile aggregates federal enforcement records on PERKINS CINDERS, INC. from every major federal compliance and enforcement source plus the UVA Corporate Prosecution Registry. OSHA workplace safety inspections, WHD wage cases, MSHA mine safety, EPA environmental enforcement, NLRB labor relations, OFLC visa/labor certification, FMCSA motor carrier registration, SAM.gov debarments, CMS nursing-home records, BLS industry safety benchmarks, OSHA ITA self-reported injury rates, SEC enforcement and financial disclosures, CPSC and NHTSA recalls.

Establishments are matched across agencies using normalized employer name, state, and ZIP code.

OSHA citations typically appear 3–8 months after the inspection, so very recent enforcement actions may not yet be reflected. Profiles may be incomplete if the establishment operates under multiple legal names or files under variations our entity-matching rules don’t yet cover. To report a missing record or correction, email corrections@fastdol.com.

Need API access, bulk download, or licensed redistribution? The website is free. Programmatic and licensed access is handled separately.

Contact sales →

Frequently asked

What is PERKINS CINDERS, INC.'s OSHA violation history?
PERKINS CINDERS, INC. has 2 OSHA inspections on record with 1 violation and $0 in total penalties.
How does PERKINS CINDERS, INC.'s safety record compare to its industry?
PERKINS CINDERS, INC. operates in the construction sand and gravel mining industry. The industry average Total Recordable Incident Rate (TRIR) is 1.5.